Member Login
member
passwd
remember me on
this computer.

- join now -
- forgot username or password? -

Search

Jump to a Date

Sponsored Communities
Cool stuff
Select a topic of interest:
...and press:
Neat Stuff
Control.com Stuff

Visit our shop for nerds in control lifestyle products.

Fortune
"Right now I'm having amnesia and deja vu at the same time."
-- Steven Wright
RSS Feed
RSS feed Use this link to get an RSS feed of the Control.com article flow, for private, non-commercial use only:
www.control.com/rss/
To get a personalized feed, become a member at no cost.
Select a Page Style
Select one of the following styles:
- BluFu
- Classic
(cookies required)
advertisement
from the Conversion of sofware department...
Rockwell versus ABB
Software, including programming, OS issues, etc. topic
Posted by DavidS on 9 November, 2007 - 1:33 am
We have Allen Bradley 5/05 PLCs running our plants, and I am involved in a project to build a new plant using identical equipment and process but the plant control will be by ABB Freelance 800f DCS system. Is there an easy way to convert the running program files in RSLOGIX 500 to ABB Freelance?
I am familiar with Allen Bradley/Rockwell but I am not familiar with ABB Freelance.


Posted by Michael Batchelor on 9 November, 2007 - 10:25 pm
Man-hours of labor is the only way to convert it. It's probably not as much "hard" as it is "tedious" to do a straight conversion. The SLC500 instruction set has very little way-out-in-left-field-real-propeller-head capacity, so you'll find an equivalent for everything that's in the old system.

The idea of doing a straight conversion is not, however, your best approach. Your best approach is to get the concerned parties in a room and *WRITE* a real operations specification of what the system should do, then exploit the strengths of the ABB system to your advantage.

Every platform, ABB, Rockwell, Siemens, unbranded east Asian brick plcs, homegrown code, or plain old wires and relays, each has strengths and weaknesses. If you've determined beforehand, either by fiat or corporate edict, which one you'll use, then by all means ferret out and exploit the strengths of that platform to your advantage.

If you're just trying to do a straight conversion so it will "look like the old one" then don't change the platform.

Michael Batchelor
www.IndustrialInformatics.com


Posted by Curt Wuollet on 10 November, 2007 - 2:37 pm
Hear, hear!
Sometimes a particular feature can make an enormous difference in solving a particular problem. And lack thereof can really grow a program and add unfathomable complexity.  And you really see this in conversions. It's often better to rewrite. And while I understand the headache of supporting multiple  brands better than most folks, picking the best one for the job can make
a large difference over using the worst or a company standard,

Regards
cww

From Control Engineering magazine...
Related articles from Control Engineering magazine
Above articles copyright 2008 Reed Business Information. Subject to its Terms of Use.
Your use of this site is subject to the terms and conditions set forth under Legal Notices and the Privacy Policy. Please read those terms and conditions carefully. Subject to the rights expressly reserved to others under Legal Notices, the content of this site and the compilation thereof is © 1999-2008 Control Technology Corporation. All rights reserved.

Users of this site are benefiting from open source technologies, including PHP, MySQL and Apache. Be happy.

Internet Explorer 6.0 Fix

Advertisement
Our Advertisers
Help keep our servers running...
Patronize our advertisers!