Member Login
Search
Jump to a Date
Sponsored Communities
Cool stuff
Neat Stuff

Visit our shop for nerds in control lifestyle products.
Thermal Overload
The threads that wouldn't die...
- PC reliability?
- Windows, real time
- PID loops
- PCs vs. PLCs
- Replacing people
- MS 'monopoly'?
- Software quality
- Where do we go from here?
- Why pay?
- PC reliability?
- Windows, real time
- PID loops
- PCs vs. PLCs
- Replacing people
- MS 'monopoly'?
- Software quality
- Where do we go from here?
- Why pay?
Fortune
Murphy's Law is recursive. Washing your car to make it rain doesn't
work.
work.
RSS Feed
www.control.com/rss/
To get a personalized feed, become a member at no cost.
Hi, I need help.
At the end of gas pipeline, a compression of gas got 4 machines. 3 GTs equipped with Speedtronic Mark V have 50% of base load. Compressor is Nuovo Pignone PCL 602.
1 GT (a new one installed) equipped with Speedtronic Mark VI has 60% of base load. Compressor is Nuovo Pignone PCL 802.
To set all machines on REMOTE (DCS CONTROL) I think that problem appears to share the entire load.
Can I accept the different setpoint or require from the contractor to unify the setpoint for all machines?
Thanks for your help.
At the end of gas pipeline, a compression of gas got 4 machines. 3 GTs equipped with Speedtronic Mark V have 50% of base load. Compressor is Nuovo Pignone PCL 602.
1 GT (a new one installed) equipped with Speedtronic Mark VI has 60% of base load. Compressor is Nuovo Pignone PCL 802.
To set all machines on REMOTE (DCS CONTROL) I think that problem appears to share the entire load.
Can I accept the different setpoint or require from the contractor to unify the setpoint for all machines?
Thanks for your help.
Load sharing does *NOT* mean that all machines will have the same amount of load.
It means that all machines will contribute torque to the process in a stable manner, some may contribute more than others, some less than others. But, they are all "sharing" the load without any fighting of controllers.
"Load sharing" is such a misleading term, but we're stuck with it.
As for how you want to operate your plant, well, that's up to you and your supervision or management. We don't have all the information to understand the lay-out of the plant, the capabilities of the compressors, and any operating limitations of the equipment given the physical lay-out of the plant. I have been on sites where because of the location of one compressor with respect to others and differences in the compressors it was not possible to run one of the compressors at less than 60% of rated load without adversely affecting the other compressors. Perhaps, this is the case here?
But, please do try to understand that load sharing does not mean each machine will drive an equal amount of load or produce an equal amount of torque.
It means that all machines will contribute torque to the process in a stable manner, some may contribute more than others, some less than others. But, they are all "sharing" the load without any fighting of controllers.
"Load sharing" is such a misleading term, but we're stuck with it.
As for how you want to operate your plant, well, that's up to you and your supervision or management. We don't have all the information to understand the lay-out of the plant, the capabilities of the compressors, and any operating limitations of the equipment given the physical lay-out of the plant. I have been on sites where because of the location of one compressor with respect to others and differences in the compressors it was not possible to run one of the compressors at less than 60% of rated load without adversely affecting the other compressors. Perhaps, this is the case here?
But, please do try to understand that load sharing does not mean each machine will drive an equal amount of load or produce an equal amount of torque.
From Control Engineering magazine...
Related articles from Control
Engineering magazine- Tips for sustainability in manufacturing
- Deadline extended: Nominate award winning products now for upcoming competition
- Video listen in: Making Coriolis two-wire demands small sacrifices
- Fast HMI application development software
- HMIs: Rugged, instrument-grade-glass on projected capacitive touchscreens
- Third-party remote I/O available for ControlLogix, CompactLogix
- Control system and instrumentation design software
- SCADA cyber security lessons from the movie ‘Eagle Eye’
- Off-line robotics programming software with 3D simulation
- Embedded: Precise Time Protocol enables new-generation Ethernet mobile networks
Above articles copyright 2008 Reed Business Information.
Subject to its Terms of Use.
Your use of this site is subject to the terms and conditions set forth under Legal Notices and the Privacy Policy. Please read those terms and conditions carefully. Subject to the rights expressly reserved to others under Legal Notices, the content of this site and the compilation thereof is © 1999-2008 Control Technology Corporation. All rights reserved.
Our Advertisers
Help keep our servers running...
Patronize our advertisers!
Patronize our advertisers!




