Member Login
Search
Jump to a Date
Sponsored Communities
Cool stuff
Neat Stuff

Visit our shop for nerds in control lifestyle products.
Thermal Overload
The threads that wouldn't die...
- PC reliability?
- Windows, real time
- PID loops
- PCs vs. PLCs
- Replacing people
- MS 'monopoly'?
- Software quality
- Where do we go from here?
- Why pay?
- PC reliability?
- Windows, real time
- PID loops
- PCs vs. PLCs
- Replacing people
- MS 'monopoly'?
- Software quality
- Where do we go from here?
- Why pay?
Fortune
The advertisement is the most truthful part of a newspaper
-- Thomas Jefferson
-- Thomas Jefferson
RSS Feed
www.control.com/rss/
To get a personalized feed, become a member at no cost.
Can anyone Guide me on what would be the Hardware & Software Modifications that need to be carried out for replacing existing Triconex ESD system with Siemens PLC, also let us know wheter it is feasible
Though I am not very proficient on Siemens PLCs, this question nags me - why should you replace a Triconex ESD system with a general-purpose PLC?
The company I work for is one of the world's biggest oil producer. We have Triconex TMR systems for more than 20 years ranging from Version 5.x to 10.x.
TRiconex is primarily designed for safety critical applications. Putting a general-pupose PLC in place of a TMR system is definitely not a step forward. The support from Triconex has been very good. The system has been very reliable in the harsh environments of an off-shore platform or the deep desert.
I am not sponsoring a particular brand, rather cautioning you on doing soemthing that definitely won't give the best protection for your plant and equipment.
The company I work for is one of the world's biggest oil producer. We have Triconex TMR systems for more than 20 years ranging from Version 5.x to 10.x.
TRiconex is primarily designed for safety critical applications. Putting a general-pupose PLC in place of a TMR system is definitely not a step forward. The support from Triconex has been very good. The system has been very reliable in the harsh environments of an off-shore platform or the deep desert.
I am not sponsoring a particular brand, rather cautioning you on doing soemthing that definitely won't give the best protection for your plant and equipment.
Siemens Fail-safe controllers are no standard PLCs. They will do SIL3 applications nicely with a more modern hardware footprint than a TMR system of the previous generation of Fail-Safe logic solvers.
Siemens offers SIL3 qualified logic solvers from 10 to 2000 IO. Multiple safety-programming languages (LAD, CFC, CAUSE-EFFECT) and uses Profisafe, a vendor independent protocol, so you can use different IO (e.g. light curtains from another vendor).
Siemens can be used in machine and process safety.
Siemens offers SIL3 qualified logic solvers from 10 to 2000 IO. Multiple safety-programming languages (LAD, CFC, CAUSE-EFFECT) and uses Profisafe, a vendor independent protocol, so you can use different IO (e.g. light curtains from another vendor).
Siemens can be used in machine and process safety.
Triconex has installations for applications ranging from ESD, Fire & Gas, Rail, Critical control and Nuclear. It is the ONLY digital control system with Nuclear 1E approval by the NRC... Siemens can't touch it.
From Control Engineering magazine...
Related articles from Control
Engineering magazine- Automation pioneer Nels Tyring dies at 77, coined term: control system integrator
- Ethernet Direct offers industrial IP66 cameras with Power over Ethernet
- Budget-friendly temperature control unit
- Upgrading control for better polymer performance
- Software pinpoints process interactions
- BP selects SIS for UK deployment
- Automation vendors boost biofuels
- Cyber security issues take center stage in 2009
- AIC Series presents new high energy storage chokes
- Decrease arc flash risk with new motor control center option
Above articles copyright 2009 Reed Business Information.
Subject to its Terms of Use.
Your use of this site is subject to the terms and conditions set forth under Legal Notices and the Privacy Policy. Please read those terms and conditions carefully. Subject to the rights expressly reserved to others under Legal Notices, the content of this site and the compilation thereof is © 1999-2009 Control Technology Corporation. All rights reserved.
Our Advertisers
Help keep our servers running...
Patronize our advertisers!
Patronize our advertisers!




